Professor Liu Zhenhuan's "Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Head Acupuncture Therapy" Innovative Practice and Exploration of Inheritance Models

Professor Liu Zhenhuan's "Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Head Acupuncture Therapy" Innovative Practice and Exploration of Inheritance Models

Professor Liu Zhenhuan’s “Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Head Acupuncture Therapy”
Innovative Practice and Exploration of Inheritance Models

Hou Taifu¹, Gong Shaoqing¹, Liu Zhenhuan²*
1 Luohe Medical College, Luohe City, Henan Province, China, 462002;

           2 Nanhai Maternity and Children’s Hospital Affiliated to Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine, Foshan City, Guangdong Province, China, 528247

Corresponding author: Liu Zhenhuan [email protected] 

Abstract: Professor Liu Zhenhuan’s “Scalp Acupuncture Therapy for Pediatric Neurological Rehabilitation” represents an innovative integration of modern neuroscience and traditional acupuncture, which has been widely adopted worldwide. This therapeutic method has successfully provided comprehensive rehabilitation programs for a range of pediatric neurological and developmental disorders, including autism spectrum disorder (ASD), attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), cerebral palsy, intellectual developmental disabilities, and other neurodevelopmental and behavioral disorders. The therapy has demonstrated remarkable clinical efficacy and meets advanced international standards. Additionally, Professor Liu has established a sustainable talent development model through the “Master Clinician Inheritance Studio + Apprenticeship Training Base”, tailored to China’s national conditions. This model has cultivated a new generation of highly skilled professionals with solid theoretical foundations, strong clinical competencies, and excellent academic skills, thereby benefiting a broader patient population. His work provides valuable experience and a practical pathway for the inheritance and innovative development of traditional Chinese medicine, offering insights for future research and clinical applications.

Keywords: acupuncture; scalp acupuncture; pediatric neurological rehabilitation scalp acupuncture; pediatric rehabilitation; Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) inheritance

With over 40 years of dedication to clinical practice and scientific research, Professor Liu has developed an integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine rehabilitation program centered on his “Pediatric Neurological Rehabilitation Scalp Acupuncture Therapy”, yielding breakthrough outcomes in rehabilitating pediatric neurodevelopmental and behavioral disorders that meet advanced international standards.  As an active promoter of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) and acupuncture globally, Professor Liu has given lectures in over 20 countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom, and Spain. Serving as a lifelong member of multiple international academic organizations, he continues to advance the clinical application and scholarly exchange of acupuncture techniques worldwide. His ongoing efforts further drive the inheritance and innovation of technologies in the field of pediatric neurological rehabilitation.

1. Theoretical Foundations and Technical Development

Currently, acupuncture has gained acceptance in 183 countries and regions worldwide due to its safety, efficacy, convenience, and cost-effectiveness [3]. Since 1985, Professor Liu Zhenhuan has applied scalp acupuncture techniques in the clinical treatment of pediatric encephalopathy. By referencing the scalp acupuncture standards outlined in the Channel Theory Basis for the International Standard Proposal of Scalp Acupuncture Point Names [4] and integrating the experience of traditional schools such as Jiao’s Scalp Acupuncture, Lin’s Acupuncture, and Zhu’s Scalp Acupuncture, he has gradually developed the Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Scalp Acupuncture Therapy. This therapy is an innovative technique that systematically applied scalp acupuncture to pediatric encephalopathies (e.g., intellectual disability and cerebral palsy) at an early stage in China. Through 40 years of clinical practice, this therapy has been used to treat a cumulative total of over 40,000 cases of children with cerebral palsy and intellectual developmental delay from more than 20 countries globally, accumulating a robust body of evidence-based medical data [5].

Compared with traditional scalp acupuncture, Professor Liu Zhenhuan’s Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Scalp Acupuncture Therapy boasts 3 core advantages. First, it features flexible pattern identification and acupuncture point selection. In alignment with the neurodevelopmental patterns of children (e.g., critical periods for motor, language, and cognitive development), acupuncture point selection is dynamically adjusted based on individual symptoms, embodying the holistic concept of TCM—balancing local stimulation with overall regulation. Second, it offers precise, scientifically grounded localization. By integrating modern neuroanatomy (e.g., Brodmann’s functional areas and Von Economo’s brain functional localization) with the traditional system of channels, network vessels, and acupuncture points, it achieves dual-dimensional localization of “functional areas + acupuncture points”. For instance, in children with delayed language development, simultaneous needling of Broca’s area (Brodmann areas 44/45) and Wernicke’s area (Brodmann area 22) is employed to promote compensation of language centers. Third, it uses a safe and painless needling technique. A rapid needling method with a small angle (15–30°) and shallow depth is used to avoid piercing the periosteum, ensuring minimal discomfort for children. This approach fosters a calm and cooperative rehabilitation environment, enhancing treatment compliance and interactive engagement.

2. International Recognition Grounded in Evidence-Based Medicine

Studies have confirmed that the Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Scalp Acupuncture Therapy, when combined with rehabilitation training (physical therapy [PT], occupational therapy [OT], and speech therapy [ST]), yields significant efficacy in pediatric neurodevelopmental and behavioral disorders. For instance, 59.5% of children with cerebral palsy showed improvement in cerebral dysplasia as indicated in cranial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans, a rate significantly higher than the 11% observed in the group receiving only motor training [6]. Single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) revealed that the brain function recovery rate in the treatment group (81.25%) was markedly higher than that in the control group (20.68%) [7]. Systematic meta-analyses further demonstrated that by promoting brain cell repair and neural network remodeling, this therapy effectively improves outcomes in intelligence tests (e.g., the Gesell Developmental Schedule) and language expression abilities (e.g., the S-S Language Assessment) [8-9]. For children with autism, the application of the “Arouse the Brain and Quiet the Mind Scalp Acupuncture Therapy”, targeting the inferior frontal gyrus (Brodmann areas 11/47) and the temporal 3-needle points (Brodmann areas 20/22), significantly reduced stereotypical behaviors and improved social interaction [10].

At the same time, the research team pioneered the use of cranial imaging (MRI/CT) and functional imaging (PET/SPECT/fMRI/DTI) to evaluate the efficacy of scalp acupuncture, generating key data on improved cerebral blood flow and enhanced neuroplasticity [11-13]. Shallow acupuncture stimulation in the somatosensory cortex, motor cortex, and language areas (Broca’s and Wernicke’s areas) was shown to induce greater neural activation [14]. Retaining needles during concurrent PT, ST, or OT further enhanced the efficacy of scalp acupuncture [15]. Innovations such as rehabilitative motor scalp acupuncture therapy—integrating target-oriented and task-oriented training with scalp acupuncture—have demonstrated positive effects on language disorders, intellectual disabilities, and recovery of gross motor function. For example, combining upper limb paralysis treatment with music occupational therapy (MOT), including targeted music-oriented OT using New Orleans music and percussion instruments, has shown promising results [16]. These findings provide robust empirical support for the scientific validity of acupuncture medicine. Notably, key outcomes have been incorporated into the Chinese Guidelines for Cerebral Palsy Rehabilitation, furthering the internationalization of acupuncture in medicine.

3. Multi-Target Regulatory Theory of Neurorepair

Previous studies have confirmed the remarkable clinical efficacy of scalp acupuncture in treating cerebral palsy, significantly improving children’s intellectual function [17]. Through 40 years of clinical practice, this therapy has treated over 40,000 cases of children with cerebral palsy and delayed intellectual development from more than 20 countries worldwide, accumulating extensive experience in pediatric neurorehabilitation through acupuncture[18]. The Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Scalp Acupuncture Therapy ​stimulates specific acupuncture points and functional brain regions, which has been shown to increase local cerebral blood flow (CBF) [19], upregulate the expression of neurotrophic factors (e.g., BDNF, NGF), and enhance nerve growth-related proteins, providing a biological basis for neurorepair [20-21]. By activating Brodmann functional areas (e.g., the motor cortex [Area 4] and sensory cortex [Areas 3/1/2]) and neural networks (e.g., the corticospinal tract and arcuate fasciculus), it promotes compensatory reorganization of damaged brain regions. For example, synchronous stimulation of the Broca-Wernicke areas in children with delayed language development can reconstruct language transmission pathways. Aligned with the pediatric neurodevelopmental principle of proceeding “from head to toe and from gross to fine motor skills”, the therapy strategically selects target stimulation areas based on developmental stages. For instance, it prioritizes the motor cortex in children aged 0–1 year, strengthens the language cortex between ages 1 and 2, and focuses on the cognitive cortex by 2–3 years. This staged approach aligns with the neuroplasticity of critical developmental periods, maximizing functional compensation.

4. Inheritance and Development

To address the challenges of “inheritance gaps” and “insufficient innovation” in TCM, Professor Liu Zhenhuan has explored a dual-track model of “Master Clinician Inheritance Studio + Apprenticeship Training Base” based on the Chinese national context. Centered on a combination of “intensive training + supervised ward rounds”, 6 online and offline academic seminars are held annually, personally guided by Professor Liu Zhenhuan. These seminars focus on cultivating young talent with both a solid theoretical foundation and strong practical skills. Currently, over 30 inheritance bases have been established in more than 30 provinces and cities throughout China (e.g., Dongguan, Zhanjiang, and Kunming). Through a “3-year apprenticeship under master physicians + clinical practice assessment” framework, the program integrates TCM principles, including pattern identification and holistic treatment concepts, with modern neuroscience. This ensures that apprentices master the core techniques of scalp acupuncture, meet national postgraduate medical training standards, and develop capabilities for independent teaching and mentoring. To date, this model has trained 26 doctoral and graduate students, with a total of over 230 apprentices, covering most provinces in China and forming a communication network “rooted in local regions and radiating to surrounding areas”. As regional academic leaders, these apprentices have not only elevated local pediatric rehabilitation diagnosis and treatment standards, but also optimized the therapy through feedback from clinical practice, driving technological iteration (e.g., upgraded scalp acupuncture protocols integrating music therapy and smart devices).

5. Research-Driven Standardization and Internationalization of the Therapy

In 2022, Professor Liu Zhenhuan led the initiation of a multicenter research project titled “International (China-Singapore) tDCS (transcranial direct current stimulation) Combined with Scalp Acupuncture for Psychobehavioral Disorders in Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD)”. In China, this project is coordinated by Foshan Nanhai Maternity and Children’s Hospital Affiliated to Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine, and conducted collaboratively with inheritance bases of “Professor Liu Zhenhuan’s Master Clinician Inheritance Studio” (including those in Dongguan, Zhanjiang, Luoding, Meizhou, Guangzhou, Kunming, and other regions). Internationally, the project is overseen by the National University of Singapore. Professor Liu serves as the chief researcher for the Chinese region, exploring novel integrative Chinese-Western intervention approaches. This initiative not only marks his widespread recognition in the international academic community, but also propels the pediatric rehabilitation division of Nanhai Maternity and Children’s Hospital, along with its inheritance bases, into a new phase of development.

Preliminary findings from a randomized controlled trial (RCT) on tPCS (transcranial pulsed current stimulation) targeting the prefrontal cerebellum in children with ASD aged 3 to 14 revealed that 20 sessions over 4 weeks significantly improved social functioning and sleep quality [22], indirectly validating the therapeutic mechanisms of the Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Scalp Acupuncture Therapy. In the same year, collaborations with institutions such as the Shenzhen Institutes of Advanced Technology (Chinese Academy of Sciences) and the Fifth Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University further advanced the clinical application of Professor Liu’s patented product, the “Intelligent Scalp Acupuncture Therapeutic Device Based on Laser Acupuncture Technology”. This innovation addresses the historical reliance on experiential operation in traditional scalp acupuncture by integrating precise localization, dosage control, and efficacy monitoring, thereby driving the standardization and broader adoption of the Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Scalp Acupuncture Therapy.

5. Clinical Case Example

A male child, 4 years and 4 months of age, was admitted to the hospital on April 16, 2021, due to “delayed language development for over 2 years”. The child began to intentionally call out to others at 14 months of age, using reduplicated syllables and imitating instructions. By age 2, he stopped speaking, rarely responded to others, and could no longer imitate speech. He only called “Mama” when crying or seeking attention, with no other verbal communication. He rarely used gestures, required parental hand-leading to retrieve objects when in need, and could not point to objects or nod/shake his head to indicate yes/no. He showed no response to instructions or reaction to his name, had poor eye contact, preferred solitary play, and had not received prior systematic rehabilitation treatment. His birth and family histories were unremarkable.

Physical Examination: Vital signs: T 36.4°C, P 102 bpm, R 24 breaths/min; height 110 cm, weight 18.0 kg. He was alert with normal mental status and reactivity, no distinctive facial features, dull expression, pale tongue with white fur, and deep-fine pulse. No abnormalities were noted in the heart, lungs, or abdomen. Gait coordination was slightly impaired, and neurological signs were unremarkable.

Behavioral Observations: The patient exhibited eye contact lasting 2–3 seconds and poor sitting tolerance. He followed instructions at a 3/10 level, was cooperative during physical examination, and was slightly emotionally sensitive. He occasionally responded to his name, called “Mama” when crying, and could imitate 6–7-character phrases. He exhibited no stereotypical behaviors; he could identify facial features and body parts, but demonstrated no spontaneous speech. He often talked to himself. preferred solitary play, and was unable to engage in cooperative games. He showed attachment to family members, could feed himself, put on shoes independently, and manage self-care (e.g., toileting).

Auxiliary Examinations:

Parent Rating Scale for Childhood Autism (PARS): Total score 118.

Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS): 38, indicating “severe autistic symptoms” [23].

Language Function Assessment (S-S): Stage 3-1; language comprehension, expression, and operational tasks were significantly below age norms. During testing, the child showed average emotional state but poor cooperation and attention, requiring occasional prompts.

Gesell Developmental Schedule: Moderate developmental delay. Adaptive behavior DA: 26.6 months (DQ: 52); gross motor DA: 25.67 months (DQ: 51); fine motor DA: 31.97 months (DQ: 63, mild delay); language DA: 8.17 months (DQ: 16, severe delay); personal-social DA: 24.27 months (DQ: 48, moderate delay).

Infant-Junior High School Social Life Ability Scale: Total score 26, standard score 7, indicating “moderate impairment”.

Auditory behavioral responses were intact. Routine blood tests, biochemical tests, cranial CT, and EEG showed no abnormalities.

Diagnoses:

International Classification of Diseases, 10th Revision (ICD-10): 1. Autism; 2. Moderate intellectual developmental delay.

Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM): Feeble-mindedness (liver and kidney depletion pattern).

Acupuncture Treatment: Professor Liu’s Pediatric Scalp Acupuncture was initiated in combination with structured social rehabilitation training. The protocol chosen was Professor Liu’s “Painless Pediatric Scalp Acupuncture Therapy”, targeting the following areas: 5 acupuncture points in the visual cortex area; Brodmann areas 17, 18, and 19 in the occipital lobe; 5 acupuncture points in Broca’s area (Brodmann area 45); and the “9 Acupuncture Points of Wisdom”. Treatment frequency was once every other day, with a 15-day break after 10 sessions (total 30 sessions per course of treatment). Since morning and daytime are considered “yang” while afternoon and nighttime are “yin”, sessions were scheduled in the morning to enhance the child’s “yang” energy, regulate yin-yang balance, and free the channels and network vessels. Needles were retained for approximately 1 hour before removal, with concurrent training during retention [24].

Outcome: After more than 6 months of treatment, the child’s eye contact improved to 4–5 seconds and instruction compliance reached 8/10. He responded to his name, spoke 6–9-word sentences spontaneously, answered simple questions, and distinguished colors, sizes, and shapes. He performed addition/subtraction up to 10 and engaged in significantly more social interactions. Efficacy was evaluated using the Gesell Developmental Schedule. Pre- and post-treatment assessments were conducted by the hospital’s Child Psychological Development Evaluation Room. Developmental age (DA) and developmental quotient (DQ) were calculated as: DQ = (DA / chronological age) × 100 [25]. A score ≥85 indicates normal development; 55–84: mild delay; 40–54: moderate delay; <40: severe delay (higher scores reflect better adaptive, language, and personal-social abilities) [24]. Other assessments used included S-S language assessment, Infant-Junior High School Social Life Ability Scale (SM; higher scores indicate better ability), Parent Rating Scale for Childhood Autism (ABC; lower scores indicate milder symptoms), and CARS (lower scores indicate improvement) [25]. Changes in pre- and post-treatment scores are shown in Table 1.

Table 1. Comparison of Assessment Results on Scales Such as Gesell, S-S, SM, ABC, and CARS Before and After Treatment

ItemAdaptability (DQ)Gross Motor (DQ)Fine Motor (DQ)Personal-Social (DQ)S-S (DQ)SM (Standard Score)ABCCARS
Before Treatment52516348Stage 3-1711838
After Treatment60748076Stage 4-291219

Note: DQ = Developmental Quotient; Assessment Times (Before Treatment: April 2021; After Treatment: October 2021).

​Follow-up: After 2 years, the child had successfully integrated into society, enrolled in school, and performed at a mid-to-high academic level.

6. Conclusion

Professor Liu Zhenhuan’s Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Scalp Acupuncture Therapy, supported by evidence-based medicine and integrating traditional acupuncture with modern neuroscience, has provided an innovative solution for pediatric neurodevelopmental and behavioral disorders. Its “Master Clinician Inheritance Studio + Apprenticeship Training Base” model has addressed the challenges in TCM inheritance, cultivating a cohort of interdisciplinary talent with both robust theoretical knowledge and strong practical skills.

Looking ahead, future efforts should focus on: (1) advancing international multicenter studies and academic exchanges to promote the inclusion of this therapy in clinical guidelines of more countries; (2) leveraging multi-omics technologies (genomics, proteomics) to elucidate the molecular mechanisms underlying scalp acupuncture’s regulation of neurodevelopment; and (3) integrating digital tools (e.g., virtual reality for simulated acupuncture) to enhance training efficiency and quality, thereby refining the inheritance system. These initiatives aim to nurture a new generation of TCM acupuncturists with solid theoretical foundations, top-tier clinical competence, and academic growth [26]. The successful implementation of this system offers a replicable “TCM role model” for the modern inheritance of traditional medicine, meriting broader promotion and application.

References

  1. 中醫兒科專家——劉振寰教授[J].中醫兒科雜誌,2012,8(06):2.
  2. 宋虎杰,中醫兒科臨床診療指南——孤獨症譜系障礙(制訂).陝西省,西安中醫腦病醫院,2020-01-01.
  3. 孫繼飛,劉斌,詹松華等.針灸腦效應的影像學研究現狀、挑戰與機遇[J].中國中西醫結合影像學雜誌,2022,20(01):1-4+10.
  4. 張世雄.“頭針穴名國際標準化方案”的絡經學基礎[C]//中國中醫科學院針灸研究所.世界針灸學會聯合會成立暨第一屆世界針灸學術大會論文摘要選編.北京市鼓樓中醫醫院;,1987:1.
  5. 錢旭光,金炳旭,張裕斌,等.頭針治療不同月齡早產兒腦損傷療效觀察[J].中國針灸,2018,38(07):723-726.
  6. 劉振寰,祁岩超,潘佩光,等.針刺對腦癱患者康復中腦功能代償作用的影響[J].上海針灸雜誌,2011,30(01):11-13.
  7. Liu ZH. Clinical Research on Improving the Brain SPECT of Children with Cerebral Palsy by Acupuncture. AOCCN 2009 10th Asian & Oceania Congress of Child Neurology and 32nd Congress of the Korean Child  eurology Society (Korea), 2009: P I-59.
  8. Lee B, Lee J, Cheon JH, Sung HK, Cho SH, Chang GT. The Efficacy and Safety of Acupuncture for the Treatment of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2023 Feb 4;2023:9840285. 
  9. 李諾. 醒神開竅頭針療法治療自閉症的臨床研究[D]. 廣東:廣州中醫藥大學,2010.
  10. Li X, Li JC, Lu QQ, Zhang F, Zhang SQ. Research status and prospects of acupuncture for autism spectrum disorders. Front Psychiatry. 2023 May 25;14:942069. 
  11. Liu ZH, Li YR, Lu YL, Chen JK. Clinical research on intelligence seven needle therapy treated infants with brain damage syndrome.Chin J Integr Med. 2016;22(6):451-456. 
  12. Zhang Y, Lan R, Wang J, et al. Acupuncture reduced apoptosis and up-regulated BDNF and GDNF expression in hippocampus following hypoxia-ischemia in neonatal rats.J Ethnopharmacol.2015;172:124-132. 
  13. Liu ZH, Qi YC, Pan PG, Ma MM, Qian XG, Fu WJ. Clinical observation on treatment of clearing the Governor Vessel and refreshing the mind needling in neural development and remediation of children with cerebral palsy.Chin J Integr Med. 2013;19(7):505-509. 
  14. 詹松華,孔營楠,譚文莉.功能磁共振成像在針灸腦效應機制研究中的應用[J].診斷學理論與實踐,2017,16(02):137-140.
  15. 周麗.焦氏頭針配合下肢陽經針刺治療痙攣型雙癱運動功能障礙的臨床觀察[D].福建中醫藥大學,2021.
  16. 李高恩.頭針治療小兒腦癱的系統評價及頭針聯合撳針治療小兒腦癱運動功能障礙的臨床療效研究[D].成都中醫藥大學,2021.
  17. 李景磊,辛茜,馬龍等.基於JAK2/STAT3信號探討頭針結合艾幼灸機制對缺氧腦癱鼠模型的及作用[J].現代生物醫學進展,2022,22( 03):427-431.
  18. 錢旭光,金炳旭,張裕斌,等.頭針治療不同月齡早產兒腦損傷療效觀察[J].中國針灸,2018,38(07):723-726.
  19. 劉振寰,錢旭光,劉冬雪.小兒腦性癱瘓腦血流動力學的研究[J].中西醫結合心腦血管病雜誌,2005,(08):677-679.
  20. 盧詠琳(Janet Wing lam Lo). 激光針灸與傳統針剌治療腦性癱瘓兒童的臨床研究[D].廣州中醫藥大學,2015.
  21. 蔡淑英,劉振寰,彭桂蘭,等.通督醒神針刺法治療早產兒腦白質損傷療效觀察[J].中國針灸,2018,38(01):51-54+58.
  22. Liu Z, Zhong S, Ho RCM, Qian X, Tang Y, Tian H, Zhang C, Li N, Zhao Y, Zhang Y, Liu H, Wu M, Zhan Y, Li M, Lv Z, Hao F, Tam W, Bingyuan JL, Pascual-Leone A. Transcranial Pulsed Current Stimulation and Social Functioning in Children With Autism: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Netw Open. 2025 Apr 1;8(4):e255776.
  23. 李宇,陳啟慧,吳若豪,等.Helsmoortel-Van der Aa綜合徵的臨床診斷和文獻復習[J].溫州醫科大學學報,2023,53(10):834-838.
  24. 《實用兒童針灸學圖譜》出版信息[J].中國兒童保健雜誌,2019,(第9期):284-285.
  25. 黃啟軍,向星霖,周坤,等.頭針結合康復訓練治療兒童自閉症伴認知障礙33例臨床觀察[J].中醫兒科雜誌,2022,18(03):83-86.
  26. 王曉坤,徐愛軍.傳承渠道對中醫針灸傳承效果的影響[J].中華中醫藥雜誌,2023,38(03):1295-1298.

劉振寰教授“小兒神經康復頭針療法”創新實踐與傳承模式探索

侯太甫1,鞏少青1,劉振寰2*

(1漯河醫學高等專科學校,河南省漯河市,462002;2廣州中醫藥大學附屬南海婦產兒童醫院,佛山528247)

通訊作者:劉振寰[email protected]

摘要:劉振寰教授的“小兒神經康復頭針療法”是融合現代神經科學與傳統針灸學創新技術,在全球範圍內得到廣泛應用。已成功地為全球範圍內的自閉症、小兒多動症、小兒腦癱及智力發育障礙、兒童神經及發育行為障礙等疾病提供整體康復方案,且療效顯著,達到國際先進水平。其創立的“名醫傳承工作室+師承弟子傳承基地”模式是適合中國國情的發展模式,培養出理論基礎扎實、臨床實踐能力強,學術一流的新一代專業人才,讓更多患者受益。為傳統中醫的傳承和創新發展提供了經驗和實踐路徑。

關鍵詞:針灸;頭針療法;小兒神經康復頭針療法;兒童康復;中醫傳承

振寰教授從事臨床與科研工作40餘年,其主導的“小兒神經康復頭針療法”為核心的中西醫康復方案,在兒童神經發育行為疾病康復領域取得突破性成果,達國際先進水平。 劉振寰教授先後赴美國、英國、西班牙等20餘國講學,擔任多個國際學術組織終身會員,在全球範圍內推動針灸技術的臨床應用與學術交流。持續推動小兒神經康復領域的技術傳承與創新。

1.理論基礎與技術形成

目前針灸因其安全、有效、方便、經濟在國際上已被183個國家及地區接受﹝3﹞。劉振寰教授自1985年開始將頭針技術應用於小兒腦病臨床治療,參照《“頭針穴名國際標準化方案”的絡經學基礎》頭針標準[4],融合焦氏頭針、林氏針灸、朱氏頭針等傳統流派經驗,逐步形成“小兒神經康復頭針療法”。該療法是國內較早將頭針系統應用於小兒腦病(如智力低下、腦癱)的創新技術,曆經40年臨床實踐,已累計治療全球20餘國腦癱、智力發育遲滯患兒4萬餘例,積累了豐富的循證醫學數據[5]

劉振寰教授的“小兒神經康復頭針療法”與傳統頭針相比,具有三大核心優勢:首先辯證配穴靈活,基於兒童神經發育規律(如運動、語言、認知發育關鍵期),結合個體症狀動態調整選穴,體現中醫的整體觀(兼顧局部刺激與整體調節)。其次定位精準科學,融合現代神經解剖學(Brodmann功能分區、Von Economo腦功能定位)與傳統經絡腧穴系統,實現“功能區+穴位”雙維度定位。例如,語言發育遲緩患兒採用Broca區(44/45區)與Wernicke區(22區)同步針刺,促進語言中樞代償。第三點是施針技術安全無痛,採用15-30°快速進針法(角度小、深度淺),避免刺及骨膜,患兒無明顯痛感,不哭不鬧,快樂康復,提高治療依從性和互動度。

  1. 基於循證醫學的國際認可

研究證實“小兒神經康復頭針療法”配合康復訓練(PT/OT/ST)在兒童神經發育行為疾病中療效顯著。59.5%的腦癱患兒大腦發育不良頭顱磁共振成像(MRI)顯示改善,遠高於單純運動訓練組的11%[6];單光子發射計算機斷層掃描(SPECT)顯示,治療組腦功能恢復率(81.25%)顯著高於對照組(20.68%)[7]。系統薈萃分析顯示“小兒神經康復頭針療法”通過促進腦細胞修復與神經網絡重塑,患兒在智力測試(如Gesell量表)、語言表達能力(如S-S語言評估)等方面的療效均有效改善[8-9]。針對自閉症患兒應用“醒腦寧神頭針療法”(靶向額下回BA11/47區、顳三針BA20/22區),可顯著降低刻板行為、改善社交互動[10]

同時研究團隊首次將頭顱影像學(MRI/CT)、功能影像學(PET/SPECT/fMRI/DTI)等技術應用於頭針療效評估,獲取了腦血流改善、神經可塑性增強等關鍵數據[11-13],淺針刺在軀體感覺區、運動區和語言區(Broca區和Wernicke區)呈現更多激活[14]。帶針做相應的 PT、ST、OT 會提升頭針效果[15]。頭針針刺目標導向訓練、任務導向訓練之康復運動頭針療法。如上肢癱瘓一與音樂作業治療(MOT) 相結合,目標音樂導向 OT,奧爾良音樂,打擊樂器等。對語言障礙、智力障礙、粗大運動功能恢復都有積極作用[16]。為針灸醫學的科學性提供了實證支持。相關成果被寫入《中國腦性癱瘓康復指南》,推動了針灸醫學的國際化進程。

  1. 多靶點調節的神經修復理論

3. Multi-Target Regulatory Theory of Neurorepair

既往研究證實中,頭針治療腦癱臨床效果卓越,可顯著改善患兒智力[17]。曆經40年收治全世界20多個國家的腦癱患兒、精神發育遲滯患兒4萬多例為小兒神經康復積累了大量臨床針灸經驗[18]。“小兒神經康復頭針療法”針刺刺激相應的學位和功能區可增加局部腦血流量(CBF)[19],提升神經營養因子(如BDNF、NGF)及神經生長相關蛋白的表達,為神經修復提供物質基礎[20-21]。通過激活Brodmann功能區(如運動區4區、感覺區3/1/2區)及神經網絡(如皮質脊髓束、弓狀束),促進損傷腦區的代償性重搆。例如,針對語言發育遲緩患兒的Broca-Wernicke區同步刺激,可重建語言傳導通路。基於兒童神經發育“從頭到尾、從粗到精”的規律,分階段選擇針刺的靶區(如0-1歲側重運動區、1-2歲強化語言區、2-3歲聚焦認知區),匹配發育關鍵期的神經可塑性,實現功能最大化代償。

  1. 傳承與發展

針對中醫“傳承斷層”與“創新不足”的痛點,劉振寰教授從國情出發,探索出“名醫傳承工作室+師承弟子傳承基地”雙軌模式。以“集中培訓+帶教查房”為核心,每年開展6次線上線下學術研討,由劉振寰教授親自指導,重點培養理論扎實、實操過硬的青年骨幹。目前已在全國30餘省市設立傳承基地(如東莞、湛江、昆明等),通過“三年跟師學習+臨床實踐考核”,把中醫辨證施治、整體觀念與現代神經科學完美結合,確保弟子掌握頭針核心技術,達到國家規培醫師標準,具備獨立授課與帶徒能力。該模式已培養博士、碩士研究生26名,師承弟子230餘人,覆蓋全國多數省份,形成“根植一方、輻射週邊”的傳播網絡。基地弟子作為區域學術帶頭人,不僅提升了當地兒童康復診療水平,更通過臨床實踐反饋優化療法,推動技術迭代(如結合音樂治療、智能設備的頭針升級方案)。

5.科研推動技術標準化與國際化

2022年,劉振寰教授牽頭啟動“國際(中國-新加坡)tDCS(經顱直流電刺激)聯合頭針治療自閉症兒童心理行為障礙”多中心科研項目。本項目中國區由廣州中醫藥大學附屬佛山市南海區婦幼保健院牽頭負責,聯合“劉振寰名醫傳承工作室”傳承基地(東莞、湛江、羅定、梅州、廣州、昆明等地區)醫院共同開展。國際區由新加坡國立大學負責。劉振寰教授擔任此項目中國區科研總負責人,探索中西醫結合干預的新方法。標志着其在國際學術界被廣泛認可,南海區婦幼保健院兒童康復領域進入一個新的發展階段。其傳承基地在兒童康復領域也將一起步入一個全新的發展階段。

研究結果顯示3至14歲ASD 兒童的額葉前小腦tPCS的隨機臨床試驗中,為期4週的20次治療改善了社交功能和睡眠[22]。間接驗證了“小兒神經康復頭針療法”的治病機理。同年又聯合澳門科技大學、中國科學院深圳先進研究院、中山大學第五附屬醫院等機構,基於“激光針灸技術”,通過精準定位、劑量控制及療效監測,實現劉振寰教授的專利產品“基於激光針灸技術的智能化頭針治療儀”的臨床轉化,解決傳統頭針操作依賴經驗的瓶頸,推動“小兒神經康復頭針療法”的技術標準化與普及化。

5. 醫案舉隅

患兒男,4歲4月,因“語言發育落後2年餘”於2021年04月16日入院。患兒14月齡開始有意識喊人,會說疊音字,有指令性仿說。2歲開始不說話,不愛搭理人,仿說不可,僅在哭鬧或找人時喊”媽媽”,無其他言語溝通,極少運用手勢,有需求時會拉父母的手取物,不會用手指物,不會點頭、搖頭示意。無指令性,叫名無反應,眼神交流差,喜歡獨自玩耍,病後未就診和系統康復治療,出生史、家族史無特殊。

體格檢查:T36.4℃,P102次/分 R:24次/分,身高110cm,體重18.0kg,神清,精神、反應可,無特殊外貌,表情呆滯,舌淡苔白,脈沉細,心肺腹無異常,行走協調性較差,神經系統體徵無異常。

行為觀察:眼神交流2-3秒,安坐欠佳,指令聽從性3/10,配合查體,情緒稍敏感,叫名偶有反應,哭鬧時會喊”媽媽”,能仿說6-7個字,無刻板行為,能指認五官及身體部位,無主動性語言,常自言自語,喜歡獨自玩耍,不能參加合作性游戲,對親人較依戀,能自己吃飯、穿鞋,二便能自理。

輔助檢查:

兒童孤獨症家長評定量表總分118分;

孤獨症評定量表(CARS):38分,提示該兒童存在明顯而嚴重的孤獨症症狀[23]

語言功能評定(S-S):階段3-1,患兒語言理解、表達及操作性課題均與正常同齡兒童不相符,在檢測過程中孩子情緒一般,配合欠佳,注意力表現欠佳,有時需要提示與提醒。

Gesell檢查:中度發育遲緩,適應性DA:26.6月,DQ:52分,提示中度發育遲緩;大運動DA:25.67月,DQ:51分,提示中度發育遲緩;精細動作DA:31.97月,DQ:63分,提示輕度發育遲緩;語言DA:8.17月,DQ:16分,提示極重度發育遲緩;個人-社交DA:24.27月,DQ:48分,提示中度發育遲緩;

嬰兒-初中生社會生活能力量表:總分26分,標準分7分,提示中度問題;

聽性行為反應通過。血常規、血生化、頭顱CT平掃、腦電圖等檢查未見異常。

根據國際疾病分類第10版(ICD-10)診斷標準:1.孤獨症2.中度精神發育遲緩;中醫診斷痴呆(肝腎虧虛證),入院後行劉氏小兒頭針結合結搆化社交康復訓練。

針灸治療方案:選擇劉振寰教授“小兒神經康復無痛頭針療法”。方案是視區5針和枕葉17、18、19區,Broca區(45區)5針,智九針。治療療程為隔日一次,每針10次,休息15天,共30次/療程,上午為陽下午為陰,白天為陽,夜為陰,我們多選擇早上進行針刺治療,提高患兒陽氣,調節陰陽,疏通經絡,並帶針訓練,留針1小時左右出針[24]

經過半年多的訓練患兒眼神交流約4-5秒,指令聽從能完成8/10,叫名有反應,能主動說6-9字句,可回答簡單問題,能分辨顏色、大小、形狀,能進行10以內加減運算,與人互動明顯增多,通過參考格塞爾(Gesell)量表評分得出療效情況。治療前後均由我院兒童心理發育評估室進行Gesell兒童發育量表評估,根據患兒在適應性、粗大運動、精細運動、語言、個人-社交5個能區的表現,評分得出發育年,Gesell 量表得分=發育年齡生理年齡x100[25]。≧85 分為正常,55~84分為輕度,40~54分為中度,<40分為重度,得分越高,表示適應性、語言、個人-社交能力越好[24]。還參考S-S語言評估量表、嬰兒-初中生社會生活能力量表(SM)分數越高能力越強,兒童孤獨症家長評定量表(ABC)和孤獨症評定量表(CARS)則相反,分數越低,孤獨症的症狀則減輕,病情好轉[25]。治療前後分數變化見表1:

表1 治療前後Gesell/S-S/SM/ABC/CARS等量表評估結果對比

項目適應性(DQ)大運動(DQ)精細動作(DQ)語言(DQ)個人-社交(DQ)S(DQ)SM(標準分)ABCCARS
治療前5251631648階段3-1711838
治療後6074807676階段4-291219

注:DQ=發育商;評估時間(治療前:2021年4月;治療後:2021年10月)

隨訪2年,孩子已經順利融入社會,踏進學校大門,學習成績中上等水平。

6.小結

劉振寰教授的“小兒神經康復頭針療法”以循證醫學為支撐,融合傳統針灸與現代神經科學,為兒童神經發育行為疾病提供了創新解決方案;其“名醫工作室+師承基地”模式則破解了中醫傳承難題,培養了一批理論與實踐能力兼具的復合型人才。

未來,需進一步通過國際多中心研究、學術交流,推動療法納入更多國家的臨床指南;利用多組學(基因組、蛋白組)技術,闡明頭針調控神經發育的分子機制;結合數字化工具(如虛擬現實模擬針刺),提升培訓效率與質量,完善傳承體系。真正培養出理論基礎扎實、臨床實踐能力一流,學術上提升的新一代中醫針灸人才[26]。該模式的成功實踐,為傳統醫學的現代化傳承提供了可復制的“中醫樣本”,值得在更大範圍推廣應用。

參考文獻

  1. 中醫兒科專家——劉振寰教授[J].中醫兒科雜誌,2012,8(06):2.
  2. 宋虎杰,中醫兒科臨床診療指南——孤獨症譜系障礙(制訂).陝西省,西安中醫腦病醫院,2020-01-01.
  3. 孫繼飛,劉斌,詹松華等.針灸腦效應的影像學研究現狀、挑戰與機遇[J].中國中西醫結合影像學雜誌,2022,20(01):1-4+10.
  4. 張世雄.“頭針穴名國際標準化方案”的絡經學基礎[C]//中國中醫科學院針灸研究所.世界針灸學會聯合會成立暨第一屆世界針灸學術大會論文摘要選編.北京市鼓樓中醫醫院;,1987:1.
  5. 錢旭光,金炳旭,張裕斌,等.頭針治療不同月齡早產兒腦損傷療效觀察[J].中國針灸,2018,38(07):723-726.
  6. 劉振寰,祁岩超,潘佩光,等.針刺對腦癱患者康復中腦功能代償作用的影響[J].上海針灸雜誌,2011,30(01):11-13.
  7. Liu ZH. Clinical Research on Improving the Brain SPECT of Children with Cerebral Palsy by Acupuncture. AOCCN 2009 10th Asian & Oceania Congress of Child Neurology and 32nd Congress of the Korean Child  eurology Society (Korea), 2009: P I-59.
  8. Lee B, Lee J, Cheon JH, Sung HK, Cho SH, Chang GT. The Efficacy and Safety of Acupuncture for the Treatment of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2023 Feb 4;2023:9840285. 
  9. 李諾. 醒神開竅頭針療法治療自閉症的臨床研究[D]. 廣東:廣州中醫藥大學,2010.
  10. Li X, Li JC, Lu QQ, Zhang F, Zhang SQ. Research status and prospects of acupuncture for autism spectrum disorders. Front Psychiatry. 2023 May 25;14:942069. 
  11. Liu ZH, Li YR, Lu YL, Chen JK. Clinical research on intelligence seven needle therapy treated infants with brain damage syndrome.Chin J Integr Med. 2016;22(6):451-456. 
  12. Zhang Y, Lan R, Wang J, et al. Acupuncture reduced apoptosis and up-regulated BDNF and GDNF expression in hippocampus following hypoxia-ischemia in neonatal rats.J Ethnopharmacol.2015;172:124-132. 
  13. Liu ZH, Qi YC, Pan PG, Ma MM, Qian XG, Fu WJ. Clinical observation on treatment of clearing the Governor Vessel and refreshing the mind needling in neural development and remediation of children with cerebral palsy.Chin J Integr Med. 2013;19(7):505-509. 
  14. 詹松華,孔營楠,譚文莉.功能磁共振成像在針灸腦效應機制研究中的應用[J].診斷學理論與實踐,2017,16(02):137-140.
  15. 周麗.焦氏頭針配合下肢陽經針刺治療痙攣型雙癱運動功能障礙的臨床觀察[D].福建中醫藥大學,2021.
  16. 李高恩.頭針治療小兒腦癱的系統評價及頭針聯合撳針治療小兒腦癱運動功能障礙的臨床療效研究[D].成都中醫藥大學,2021.
  17. 李景磊,辛茜,馬龍等.基於JAK2/STAT3信號探討頭針結合艾幼灸機制對缺氧腦癱鼠模型的及作用[J].現代生物醫學進展,2022,22( 03):427-431.
  18. 錢旭光,金炳旭,張裕斌,等.頭針治療不同月齡早產兒腦損傷療效觀察[J].中國針灸,2018,38(07):723-726.
  19. 劉振寰,錢旭光,劉冬雪.小兒腦性癱瘓腦血流動力學的研究[J].中西醫結合心腦血管病雜誌,2005,(08):677-679.
  20. 盧詠琳(Janet Wing lam Lo). 激光針灸與傳統針剌治療腦性癱瘓兒童的臨床研究[D].廣州中醫藥大學,2015.
  21. 蔡淑英,劉振寰,彭桂蘭,等.通督醒神針刺法治療早產兒腦白質損傷療效觀察[J].中國針灸,2018,38(01):51-54+58.
  22. Liu Z, Zhong S, Ho RCM, Qian X, Tang Y, Tian H, Zhang C, Li N, Zhao Y, Zhang Y, Liu H, Wu M, Zhan Y, Li M, Lv Z, Hao F, Tam W, Bingyuan JL, Pascual-Leone A. Transcranial Pulsed Current Stimulation and Social Functioning in Children With Autism: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Netw Open. 2025 Apr 1;8(4):e255776.
  23. 李宇,陳啟慧,吳若豪,等.Helsmoortel-Van der Aa綜合徵的臨床診斷和文獻復習[J].溫州醫科大學學報,2023,53(10):834-838.
  24. 《實用兒童針灸學圖譜》出版信息[J].中國兒童保健雜誌,2019,(第9期):284-285.
  25. 黃啟軍,向星霖,周坤,等.頭針結合康復訓練治療兒童自閉症伴認知障礙33例臨床觀察[J].中醫兒科雜誌,2022,18(03):83-86.
  26. 王曉坤,徐愛軍.傳承渠道對中醫針灸傳承效果的影響[J].中華中醫藥雜誌,2023,38(03):1295-1298.

NEJTCM

Rekindling the Light of Traditional Chinese Medicine
#pf-body #pf-title { margin-bottom: .3rem; border-bottom: 3px solid #007377; margin-top: 5px; font-size: 30px; }